AVCA DIII All-Americans
| Year | Name | Team |
| 2004 |
Kenny Eiser Ricky Ziegler Brian Dinning Tim Cole Ryan Genova |
First First First Second Second |
| 2005 |
Ricky Ziegler Nate Ocasio Cordt Withum Jeremy Barndt Tim Cole |
First First First First Second |
| 2006 |
Cordt Withum Matt Fritz Jeremy Barndt Matt Werle |
First First Second Second |
| 2007 |
Jeremy Barndt Nate Ocasio Matt Werle Matt Fritz |
First First First First |
| 2008 |
Matt Werle Dan Powers |
First Second |
| 2009 |
Matt Werle Dan Powers Evan Halteman |
First First Second |
| 2010 |
Anthony Damiano Zach Wanner |
First Second |
| 2011 | Chris Vrooman | First |
| 2012 |
Ben Wolff Joe Bortak |
First Second |
| 2013 |
Joe Bortak Paul Kuhn |
First Second |
| 2014 |
Joe Bortak Paul Kuhn Chad Albert Alex McColgin |
First First Second Second |
| 2015 |
Joe Bortak Paul Kuhn Chad Albert Matt Elias |
First Second Second Honorable Mention |
| 2016 |
Kyle Seeley |
Second |
| 2017 |
Kyle Seeley |
Second |
| 2018 |
Quinn Peterson |
Second |
| 2019 |
Quinn Peterson |
First |
| 2020 |
Kevin Duffy III |
Honorable Mention |
| 2021 |
Kevin Duffy III |
First |
| 2022 |
Kevin Duffy III |
Second |
Volleyball Magazine All-Americans
| 1995 | Chris Fazio |
| 1996 | Chris Fazio |
| 1997 | Chris Fazio |
| 1999 | Rob Kirby |
| 1999 | Mike Sheaffer |