CoSIDA Academic All-America College Division
| 1970 | Ray Grabiak | First Team |
| 1971 |
"Mo" Taylor Ray Grabiak |
First Team First Team |
| 1985 | Bob Crossey | Second Team |
| 1986 | Bob Crossey | Second Team |
| 1991 | New Holobinko | Second Team |
| 2003 | P.J. Brown | Second Team |
| 2004 |
Matt Garner P.J. Brown |
First Team First Team |
| 2016 | Joel Reighard | Second Team |
| 2017 | Joel Reighard | Second Team |
Don Hansen's Football Gazette All-America
| 1988 |
Mike Cottle Cubby Davis Dennis DeRenzo Frank Gay |
First Team Honorable Mention Honorable Mention Honorable Mention |
| 1990 |
Ray Shelley Brian Giachetti |
Second Team Third Team |
| 1991 | Brian Giachetti | First Team |
| 1996 | Chad Zaring | Second Team |
| 1999 | Matt Eisenberg | First Team |
| 2001 | Josh Seiders | Third Team |
Pizza Hut All-America
| 1984 | Gino Perri | Honorable Mention |
| 1985 | Gino Perri | Honorable Mention |
| 1988 | Mike Cottle | Second Team |
Champion USA All-America
| 1990 | Ray Shelley | Third Team |
Hewlett-Packard All-America
| 1996 | Chad Zaring | Third Team |
| 1999 | Matt Eisenber | Second Team |
| 2001 | Paul Evans | Honorable Mention |
Kodak All-America College Division
| 1986 | Steve Yerger | First Team |
| 1987 | Mark Dorner | First Team |
AP Little All-America
| 1948 | Dave Croft | Honorable Mention |
| 1949 |
George Smith Mike Dzvonar Dave Croft Cecil Jackson |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention Honorable Mention Third Team |
| 1954 | Joe Veto | First Team |
| 1955 |
Bill Haushalter Pat Tarquinio Barry Drexler |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention Third Team |
| 1956 |
John Staley "Moon" Mullen |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention |
| 1957 |
Bernie McQuown Bill Berrier |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention |
| 1958 | Bill Berrier | Third Team |
| 1959 |
Bob Soloman Al Dungan Bill Berrier |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention Second Team |
| 1963 | Bill Cromwell | Second Team |
| 1966 | "Bo" Berlanda | Honorable Mention |
| 1967 | Don Weiss | Honorable Mention |
| 1968 |
Jim Hartland Don Weiss |
Honorable Mention Honorable Mention |
| 1974 | Pete Lentini | Honorable Mention |
| 1984 | Dave Murphy | Honorable Mention |
| 1986 | Steve Yerger | Honorable Mention |
| 1987 | Mark Dorner | First Team |
USA College Football All-America
| 2014 |
Ward Udinski Ethan Wilt |
Third Team Honorable Mention |
BeyondSportsNetwork.com All-American
| 2013 | Brandon Felus | Second Team |
D3Football.com All-America
| 2013 | Brandon Felus | Honorable Mention |
D3Football.com All-Region
| 2013 | Brandon Felus | First Team |
| 2016 | Kirby Breault | Second Team |
