All-Landmark Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2007 | Amber Thomas, Megan Sollenberger, Paige Johnston, Erin Albert, Beth Kozak | Megan Lamens |
| 2008 | Amber Thomas, Megan Sollenberger, Cassie Dickmann, Beth Kozak | Erin Albert, Paige Johntson |
| 2009 | Paige Johnston, Megan Sollenberger, Kristen Noetzel, Stephanie Strauss, Drew Barnhart | Kelsey Fuller |
| 2010 | Kelsey Fuller, Kristin Noetzel, Stephanie Strauss, Libby Morrison | Amy Miller, Amanda Schmidt |
| 2011 | Kelsey Fuller, Ashley Schnader, Courtney Greenberg, Libby Morrison | Amy Miller |
| 2012 | Courtney Lydick, Amelia Kepler | Christine Sumner, Kelsey Fuller, Sarah McCarthy |
| 2013 | Amelia Kepler, Amy Miller, Kelly Reynolds, Nakita Gearhart | Mar-Jana Phillips, Brittani Young |
| 2014 | Kelly Reynolds, Nakita Gearhart | Mar-Jana Phillips, Megan Moroney |
| 2015 | Kelly Reynolds, Megan Moroney, Nakita Gearhart | Kristin Collins, Katie Byrne, Mar-Jana Phillips |
| 2016 | Kelly Reynolds, Katie Byrne, Nakita Gearhart, Suzanne Gloeker | Megan Moroney, Mar-Jana Phillips |
| 2017 | Marybeth Weihbrecht, Katie Byrne | Morgan Edwards, Megan Moroney, Alyssa Tavera, Victoria Taylor |
| 2018 | Morgan Edwards, Victoria Taylor, Marybeth Weihbrecht, Alyssa Tavera, Katie Byrne | Dejia Danhi |
| 2019 | Dejia Danhi, Emma Davis, Moira Folan, Victoria Taylor | Morgan Edwards |
| 2021 | Victoria Taylor, Grace Erskine, Olivia Foley | Kennedy Christy, Mackenzie Coley, Kiona Sky Rousset-Hernandez |
| 2022 | Lily Podolan, Mackenzie Coley, Olivia Foley | Kiona Sky Rousset-Hernandez, Audrey Muth |
Middle Atlantic Conference All-Stars
| 1980 | Julia George, Claudia Tweardy |
| 1981 | Claudia Tweardy, Colleen Ireland, Sue Barker |
| 1982 | Sue Barker, Colleen Ireland, Claudia Tweardy, Sue MacLachlan, Eknomy Opamayikul |
| 1983 | Peggy Evans, Ekanong Opanayikul |
| 1984 | Ekanong Opanayikul, Peggy Evans |
| 1985 | Beth Hoppel, Mariella Gacka |
| 1986 | Cathy Miller, Jackie Rebert, Beth Hoppel |
| 1987 | Beth Hoppel, Cathy Miller, Jackie Rebert |
| 1988 | Melinda Shelby, Jackie Rebert, Rhonda Bygall, Kris Witchey |
| 1989 | Kris Witchey, Melinda Selby, Rhonda Bygall, Angie Shue, Laurie Snow |
| 1990 | Gina Leis, Larissa Weimer, Michelle Wissinger |
| 1991 | Gina Leis, Christy Orndorff, Larissa Weimer |
| 1992 | Nicki Firestone, Shelly Miller, Christy Orndorff |
| 1993 | Heather Blough (1st), Niki Firestone (1st), Christy Orndorff (1st) |
| 1994 | Heather Blough (1st), Kristi Kusch (1st), Christy Orndorff (1st) |
| 1995 | Robin Diehl (1st), Marci Katona (1st), Jennifer Rebert (1st) |
| 1996 | Robin Diehl (1st), Jennifer Rebert (1st) |
| 1997 | Anne Bock (2nd), Kristin Hershey (1st), Marci Katona (2nd), Melissa Myers (1st), Jennifer Rebert (1st), Lisa Snyder (2nd) |
| 1998 | Colleen Carver (1st), Kristin Hershey (1st), Jennie Lizun (1st), Carrie Zeller (1st) |
| 1999 | Colleen Carver (1st), Kristin Hershey (1st), Jennie Lizun (2nd), Brandy Workinger (2nd), Carrie Zeller (1st) |
| 2000 | Niki Mueller (1st), Jesse Woods (1st), Brandy Workinger (1st) |
| 2001 | Carli Dale (2nd), Danielle Hart (1st), Niki Mueller (2nd), Brandy Workinger (1st) |
| 2002 | Niki Mueller (1st), Carli Dale (1st), Johanna Holtan (2nd), Katie Laucks (2nd) |
| 2003 | Carli Dale (1st), Katie Laucks (1st), Stephanie Kines (2nd), Johanna Holtan (2nd), Katie Charles (2nd) |
| 2004 | Carli Dale (1st), Katie Laucks (1st), Stephanie Kines (2nd), Katie Charles(2nd) |
| 2005 | Stephanie Kines (1st), Katie Laucks (1st), Rachel Schatz (2nd), Amber Thomas (2nd), Tara McMinn (2nd) |
| 2006 | Stephanie Kines (1st), Amber Thomas (1st) |
