Mid-Atlantic Conference: Commonwealth
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 1997 | Mike Pringle (OF) | |
| 1998 | Matt Loring (3B), David Kmett (DH) | |
| 1999 | Jason Evans (2B), Matt Eisenberg (OF) | Brook Williams (OF), Neil Yoder (C) |
| 2000 | Tim Dobson (DH), Matt Eisenberg (OF) | Lucas Kelleher (OF), Rich Kerpovich (1B) |
| 2001 | Tim Dodson (1B), Matt Eisenberg (OF), Tim Keeley (DH), Lucas Kelleher (UTL) | |
| 2002 | Tim Dobson (1B), Lucas Kelleher (OF) | |
| 2003 | David Saintz (2B) | |
| 2004 | Walt Goedkoop (1B), David Saintz (OF), Eric Hatten (RP) | Will Russell (2B), Adam Camberg (DH), Jamie Fye (SP) |
| 2005 | Will Russell (2B), Walt Goedkoop (DH) | Dan Kauffman (1B), Troy Beaver (OF), Cody Zong (SP) |
| 2006 | Zach Sternberg (C), Dan Kauffman (1B), David Saintz (OF), Troy Beaver (OF), Jeff Hayes (RP), Jason Enoch (P), Walt Goedkoop (DH) | Steven Wilk (3B) |
| 2007 | Dan Kauffman (1B) |
Landmark Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2008 | Dan Kauffman, Steve Wilk, Adam Spadafora, Jay Enoch | Greg Hoffman, Kevin Small, Andrew Kriss, Andrew Snyder |
| 2009 | Andrew Kriss, Adam Spadaforda | |
| 2010 | Greg Hoffman, Andrew Kriss, Johnny Martinez | |
| 2011 | Johnny Martinez | Matt Regan |
| 2012 | Ben Mersky | |
| 2013 | Joe Sforza | Dan Gray |
| 2014 | Cody Krepps (OF) | Joe Sforza (3B/DH), Dan Gray (C) |
| 2017 | Chris Schreder | |
| 2018 | Chris Schreder, Isaac Maclay | |
| 2019 | Adam Kipp | |
| 2021 | Isaac Maclay (1B) | Ryan McClain (OF) |
| 2022 | Isaac Maclay | |
| 2023 | Michael Warren | Corey Daniels |
