ECAC
| Year | Round-Opponent | Result |
| 2003 | First- Drew | L, 5-3 |
| 2009 | First- Misericordia | L, 6-4 |
Landmark Conference
| Year | Opponent | Result |
| 2009 |
Susquehanna Catholic Susquehanna |
L, 5-1 W, 2-0 L, 3-2 |
| 2010 |
Moravian Susquehanna Susquehanna |
L, 3-1 W, 7-6 L(8), 6-5 |
| 2013 |
Susquehanna Moravian Susquehanna |
L, 8-0 W, 4-2 L, 4-0 |
| 2017 |
Moravian Susquehanna |
L(5), 9-1 L, 5-1 |
| 2021 |
Elizabethtown (play-in game) Susquehanna Susquehanna |
W, 4-1 L, 4-1 L, 7-0 |
Middle Atlantic Conference
| Year | Opponent | Result |
| 2003 |
Moravian Elizabethtown |
L(11), 4-3 L, 2-1 |
| 2004 |
Moravian Susquehanna |
L, 5-3 L, 5-2 |
