| 1996 | Robin Diehl, Wendy Koziel, Melissa Myers, Jennifer Rebert |
| 1997 | Anne Bock, Kristin Hershey, Melissa Myers, Jennifer Rebert, Carrie Zeller |
| 1998 | Colleen Carver, Kristin Hershey, Jennie Lizun, Carrie Zeller |
| 1999 | Colleen Carver, Kristin Hershey, Carrie Zeller |
| 2000 | Danielle Hart, Jesse Woods, Brandy Workinger |
| 2001 | Carli Dale, Danielle Hart, Niki Mueller, Brandy Workinger |
| 2002 | Carli Dale, Johanna Holtan, Niki Mueller |
| 2003 | Katie Charles, Carli Dale, Johanna Holtan, Stephanie Kines, Katie Laucks |
| 2004 | Carli Dale, Stephanie Kines, Katie Laucks, Erin Wisor |
| 2005 | Stephanie Kines, Katie Laucks, Rachael Schatz, Amber Thomas |
| 2006 | Stephanie Kines, Beth Kozak, Rachael Schatz, Megan Sollenberger, Amber Thomas |
| 2007 | Amber Thomas, Megan Sollenberger, Beth Kozak, Erin Albert |
| 2008 | Amber Thomas, Beth Kozak, Megan Sollenberger, Stephanie Strauss |
| 2009 | Megan Sollenberger, Stephanie Strauss, Drew Barnhart |
| 2010 | Kelsey Fuller, Libby Morrison, Kristin Noetzel, Stephanie Strauss |
| 2011 | Courtney Greenberg, Libby Morrison |
| 2012 | Courtney Lydick |
| 2013 | Amy Miller, Amelia Kepler, Kelly Reynolds, Nakita Gearhart |
| 2014 | Nakita Gearhart, Amelia Kepler, Kelly Reynolds, Megan Moroney |
| 2015 | Nakita Gearhart, Kelly Reynolds, Megan Moroney, Katie Byrne |
| 2016 | Nakita Gearhart, Kelly Reynolds, Megan Moroney, Katie Byrne |
| 2017 | Marybeth Weihbrecht, Katie Byrne, Victoria Taylor |
| 2018 | Marybeth Weihbrecht, Katie Byrne, Dejia Danhi, Morgan Edwards, Victoria Taylor, Alyssa Tavera |
| 2019 | Emma Davis, Moria Folan, Victoria Taylor, Dejia Danhi, Morgan Edwards |
| 2021 |
Olivia Foley, Kiona Sky Rousset-Hernandez, Victoria Taylor, Grace Erskine |
| 2022 |
Kiona Sky Rousset-Hernandez, Lily Podolan, Mackenzie Coley, Olivia Foley, Audrey Muth |