Landmark Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2021 | Alex Fontes (200 Fly) |
Alex Fontes (100 Fly) Kendra White (500 Free & 400 IM) |
| 2014 |
Hillary Palmer (100 Back) Cahn, Fimple, Nye, Palmer (200 Free Relay) Cahn, Fimple, Nye, Palmer (400 Free Relay) |
Erika Fimple (100 Fly) Erika Fimple (200 Fly) Hillary Palmer (200 IM) Cahn, Fimple, Nye, Palmer (200 Medley Relay) |
| 2013 | Hillary Palmer (100 Back) | Hillary Palmer (100 Free) |
| 2012 | Kathryn Viola (200 IM) | |
| 2011 | Kelsey Miles (100 Free) | |
| 2010 | Leann Foster (1m Dive) |
Middle Atlantic Conference
| Year | Name |
| 2007 |
Kasey Brough (500 Free & 1650 Free) Brough, Sutherland, Zoubek, Almy (800 Free Relay) |
| 2006 |
Kristin Musselman (50 Free) Kasey Brough (500 Free & 1650 Free) Kim Dierolf (1650 Free) Musselman, Sutherland, Thompson, Hanson (200 Free Relay) |
| 2005 |
Kathleen Trainor (50 Free & 100 Free) Kasey Brough (500 Free) Kim Dierolf (1650 Free) Amy Sutherland (200 Back) Gais, Sweigart, Trainor, Hanson (200 Free Relay) Gais, Sutherland, Trainor, Hanson (400 Free Relay) Sutherland, Bair, Sweigart, Trainor (800 Free Relay) |
| 2004 |
Kathleen Trainor (50 Free & 100 Free) Kim Allen (100 Breast, 200 Breast, & 200 IM) Nulton, Gais, Trainor, Hanson (200 Free Relay & 400 Free Relay) Nulton, Gais, Allen, Sutherland (800 Free Relay) Sutherland, Allen, Trainor, Hanson (200 Medley Relay) |
| 2003 |
Kathleen Trainor (50 Free & 100 Free) Cynthia Long (1650 Free) Kim Allen (100 Breast & 200 Breast) Nulton, Gais, Long, Schneider (800 Free Relay) Schneider, Allen, Long, Schneider (200 Medley Relay) Gais, Allen, Long, Trainor (400 Medley Relay) |
| 2002 |
Kim Allen (100 Breast & 200 IM) Blasnak, Allen, Dorsch, Trainor (200 Medley Relay) |
| 2001 |
Danielle Irwin (50 Free & 100 Fly) Alissa Schneider (200 Fly & 400 IM) Kim Allen (100 Breast & 200 Breast) |
| 2000 |
Alissa Schneider (100 Free, 200 Free, & 400 IM) Cyndi Long (100 Fly) Schneider, Soule, Dorsch, Long (200 Free Relay & 400 Free Relay) |
| 1996 | Kirsten Kenyon (100 Back) |
| 1995 | Kirsten Kenyon (100 Back) |
