Landmark Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2007 | Sarah Ruggiero, Laura Goodlander | |
| 2008 | Melissa Johnson | Caitlin Bigelow, Laura Goodlander |
| 2009 | Melissa Johnson | |
| 2010 | Erin Eddinger, Alicia Snyder, Katie Young | |
| 2011 | Lauren Liacouras, Alicia Snyder | |
| 2012 | Alicia Snyder, Paula Pryor | |
| 2013 | Alicia Snyder, Paula Pryor, Lillian Dudek | |
| 2014 | Kerry Leonard | |
| 2017 | Kerry Leonard, Kristin Racis | |
| 2018 | Amanda Kopacz |
Mid-Atlantic Conference
| Year | Second Team |
| 2001 | Erinn Harter |
| 2002 | Nikki McLellan |
| 2003 | Nikki McLellan, Amy Tyler, Desiree Wagner, Emily Endres, Kelly Howard |
| 2004 | Nikki McLellan |
| 2005 | Nikki McLellan |
| 2006 | Melissa Johnson |