Landmark Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team |
| 2007 | Kim Wagner, Michelle Campbell, Leslie Stern, Heather Hassinger | Paula Price, Amanda Wimer, Abby Funk |
| 2008 | Erin Smith, Meghan McGlone | Paula Price, Abby Funk |
| 2009 | Meghan McGlone, Paula Price, Kim Amrod, Sam Smith | Melissa Gorman, Denalyn Spratt |
| 2010 | Kim Amrod, Paula Price, Moira Nugent, Meghan McGlone | Joyce Eveleth |
| 2011 | Meghan McGlone | Emma Dahmus, Kim Amrod |
| 2012 | Emma Dahmus | Sarah Bilheimer, Caroline Philips, Jill McNeish |
| 2013 | Emma Dahmus | Sarah Bilheimer, Kelsey Leibelsperger, Shelby Miller |
| 2014 | Sarah Bilheimer, Julianne Jones, Kelsey Leibelsperger | Allison Groft, Kourtney Showers |
| 2015 | Sarah Bilheimer, Allison Groft, Kelsey Leibelsperger | Katie Alexander, Brittany Meier, Alex Stroud |
| 2016 | Brittani LaFollette | |
| 2017 | Katie Alexander | Meredith Shephard, Grace Kuszmaul |
| 2018 | Grace Alexander, Grace Kuszmaul | |
| 2019 | Madison Miller, Nicole Piccioni | Catherine Lanigan, Grace Kuszmaul |
All-Middle Atlantic Conference
| Year | First Team | Second Team | Honorable Mention |
| 1979 | Shawn Hansen, Barbara Pearson | ||
| 1980 | Barbara Pearson, Elizabeth Abel, Nanci Young | Clair Warmerdam | |
| 1981 | Patty Price, Natalie Carabello | ||
| 1982 | Sue Occiano | ||
| 1983 | Sue Occiano | Jill Loomis, Terri Sagan | |
| 1984 | Sue Occiano | ||
| 1985 | Sue Occiano | ||
| 1986 | Amy Oiler | ||
| 1987 | Jill Schadler | ||
| 1989 | Carolyn Sheady, Amy Blough | ||
| 1991 | Carolyn Sheady, Renee Rine | ||
| 1992 | Erin Reed | ||
| 1993 | Amy Onofrey | ||
| 1994 | Nina Mathers | Erin Reed | |
| 1995 | Nina Mathers | Jessica Emrich | |
| 1996 | Nina Mathers | ||
| 1997 | Stacy Wenger, Becky Kurtz | Ellen Heinly, Danny Young | |
| 1998 | Danny Young | Hope Woolcock, Becky Koch, Kara Elias | |
| 1999 | Candy Sanders | Kara Elias, Danny Young | |
| 2000 | Jen Thew | Jeanean Chiusano, Liz Allard | |
| 2001 | Jess Hebel | Jen Goddard | |
| 2002 | Jean Silvey | Billie Rickenbaugh, Melanie Sappe' | |
| 2003 | Jean Silvey, Billie Rickenbaugh, Grace McCluskey | Dana Groft | |
| 2004 | Grace McCluskey, Billie Rickenbaugh, Janine Hartman, Melanie Sapp' | Kim Wagner, Elise Zimmerman | |
| 2005 | Elise Zimmerman | Kim Wagner, Corinne Hamblet |
