Mid-Atlantic Commonwealth Conference Players of the Year
| 1999 | Clint Wevodau (P) (Rookie) |
| 2003 | David Saintz (2B) (Rookie) |
| 2005 | Jason Enoch (INF/P) (Co-Rookie) |
| 2006 | David Enoch (Pitcher) |
Landmark Conference Players of the Year
| 2008 | Dan Kauffman (Player), Jay Enoch (Pitcher) |
| 2011 | Johnny Martinez (Player) |
| 2018 | Isaac Maclay (Rookie) |
| 2021 | Isaac Maclay (Player) |
Mid-Atlantic Commonwealth Conference Coach of the Year
| 2004 | George Zanic |
Landmark Conference Coach of the Year
| 2009 | Tom Gibboney |
